El Coyote Gordo (supergee) wrote,
El Coyote Gordo
supergee

Zero Tolerance redux

Anthony Burgess's sf novel The Wanting Seed offers a cyclical theory of history. There are two approaches: the Pelagians believe that people are good, so they set up a policy based on trusting people. When that proves disastrous, the Augustinians take over, with the theory that people need Lotsa Rules. Eventually, the rules become so oppressive that the Pelagians return, and the cycle begins.

The approach also applies to trusting those in power. Trust judges to determine criminal sentences, and after a while it is noticed that the rich people and the white people get off easy, so there is an Augustinian outcry for mandatory sentences. After a while, it is noticed that the Rules are trapping relatively harmless people in Draconian sentences.

High schools don't want kids bringing weapons to school. So they have a discretionary policy. Some of those caught are found to have relatively harmless weapons or good excuses, so they are excused. After a while it is noticed that the rich people and the white people get off easy, so there is an Augustinian outcry for Zero Tolerance (which as Bruce Schneier has pointed out, means Zero Discretion). And so on.

Announcing a Zero Tolerance Policy and not following it (as Readercon did) is the worst of both worlds.
Tags: follow-up
Subscribe

  • Plague ploys

    Today’s vote of thanks goes to the millions of white Americans (with one vote each) who know that all Asian-looking people (including those whose…

  • Victim-Blaming, as Ever

    Approximately 90% of the people with one vote each who breathed a sigh of desperate relief that they won’t have to be governed by an intelligent…

  • The War of 1619

    But what about the white people? [The Root]

  • 5 comments
  • 5 comments

Comments for this post were locked by the author